MYSTERY OF THE DEMON GATOR
Pap wasn’t the only man to attempt to hunt the demon gator. After decades of Tom’s destruction, a group of Alabamians were finally able to chase him out, all the way across the border into Northwest Florida. Some say he made a home in a pond near Esto in Holmes County where locals claim he’d let out a deep monstrous bellow every time the nearby lumber company’s whistle would go off.
Eventually sightings of Two-Toed Tom began to waver and speculation of his demise began. Then, a half century after Carmer published the story of Pap Haines, the tracks of an enormous alligator were found on a sandbar at Boynton Island on the Choctawahtchee. These monstrous footprints had two toes.
Whether these tracks were in fact Two-Toed is still a mystery to this day.